Most roofing horror stories come down to the same few things: unclear prices, surprise charges, missed appointments, sloppy cleanup, and leaks that come back with no one taking responsibility. You can avoid most of them by asking the right questions before you sign. Save this list on your phone and bring it to your estimate.
About the company
1. Are you licensed for my area?
In New York City, home improvement contractors need a license from the city's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection. Westchester County has its own home improvement license. Ask for the license number and look it up.
2. Are you insured, and can I get a certificate of insurance?
Ask for proof of liability insurance and workers' compensation. Co-op boards, condo boards and managing agents often require a certificate of insurance before work starts.
3. How do you handle complaints?
Read the reviews, including the bad ones, and pay attention to how the owner responds. A calm, specific reply that offers to fix the problem is a good sign. Insulting or threatening replies are a red flag. Also be wary of piles of short, nearly identical five-star reviews posted around the same time.
About the job
4. Can you show me photos of the problem?
You should see what they saw: the damaged flashing, the open seam, the worn shingles.
5. Does this need a repair or a replacement, and why?
When it's close, ask for both options and the trade-offs of each.
6. What exactly is included in the price?
Tear-off, disposal, deck repairs, flashing, gutters, permits and cleanup should be spelled out. Get the scope, price and schedule in writing.
7. What happens if you find hidden damage?
The right answer: they stop, show you photos, and get your written approval before doing any extra work.
8. Are there any other charges I should know about?
Ask directly about fees for tall ladders, steep roofs, debris disposal, sales tax and anything else that could show up on the final bill.
About the work days
9. When will the crew arrive, and how long will it take?
Ask for the start date, an arrival window and the expected number of days, plus what happens if weather delays the job. Ask whether you'll get a call or text if the crew is running late.
10. Do I need to be home?
For exterior work, often not, as long as the crew can reach the roof and you can be reached by phone. If you won't be there, ask for photos during and after the job.
11. How will you protect my property and clean up?
Ask about tarps over plants and windows, protecting driveways and walkways, hauling away old materials, and sweeping the yard for nails.
After the job
12. What's the warranty, and what happens if it leaks again?
Ask about the manufacturer's warranty on materials and the contractor's warranty on workmanship, and get both in writing. Then ask the practical question: if it leaks after the next storm, who do I call, and how soon will you come back?
Ask us anything
Greystone Construction Group holds NYC Home Improvement Contractor License #2098242-DCA and Westchester County License #WC-37638-H24, and is fully insured. We can provide a certificate of insurance for your co-op, condo or managing agent. Book a free estimate and bring this list. We'll answer every question.